In the name of Allah, the Most-Merciful, the All-Compassionate
“May the Peace and Blessings of Allah be Upon You”
Praise be to Allaah, we seek His help and His forgiveness. We seek refuge with Allaah from the evil of our own souls and from our bad deeds. Whomsoever Allaah guides will never be led astray, and whomsoever Allaah leaves astray, no one can guide. I bear witness that there is no god but Allaah, and I bear witness that Muhammad is His slave and Messenger.
Bismillah Walhamdulillah Was Salaatu Was Salaam ‘ala Rasulillah
As-Salaam Alaikum Wa-Rahmatullahi Wa-Barakatuhu
What was the Sign of Jonah ?
by Sheikh Ahmed Deedat
“CHRIST” NOT A NAME
Over a thousand million Christians today blindly accept that Jesus of Nazareth is the Christ. They produce “a thousand and one” prophecies from the Jewish Bible (the Old Testament) to prove their claim that Jesus was the Messiah promised to the Jews. Let us hold the “thousand” prophecies in abeyance for a moment and examine the only unequivocal claim made by Jesus in the Gospels and examine whether he fulfilled his promise to the Jews.
We must admit that the word CHRIST is not a name. It is a title. It is a translation of the Hebrew word Messiah, meaning “anointed.” The Greek word for “anointed” is Christos from which we get the word Christ.
Priests and kings were “anointed” when being consecrated to their office. The Holy Bible confers this title even on a heathen king CYRUS (Isaiah 45:1).
We are reminded in the Gospel of St. Luke that “WHEN EIGHT DAYS WERE ACCOMPLISHED FOR THE CIRCUMCISING OF THE CHILD, HIS NAME WAS CALLED JESUS, WHICH WAS SO NAMED OF THE ANGEL BEFORE HE WAS CONCEIVED IN THE WOMB.” (Luke 2:21).
The name that was given to Mary for her yet unborn son was JESUS and NOT Christ. It was only after his baptism at the hands of John the Baptist that he, Jesus, claimed to be the Christ. The Jews were not the ones to accept his claim on its face value.
They wanted proof!
MIRACLE AS PROOF
Matthew records that the learned men among the Jews – the Scribes and Pharisees – came to Jesus and asked, “MASTER, WE WOULD SEE A SIGN FROM THEE”. (Matthew 12:38).
What they really wanted was some “magic trick,” some “sleight of hand” like producing a rabbit out of a hat or walking on the water or flying in the air or trodding on burning coal. This is the type of “sign” or MIRACLE they were looking for. The Jews mistook him for a sorcerer, a wizard, a charlatan.
NO “SIGN” BUT ONE
With righteous indignation Jesus replies:
“AN EVIL AND ADULTEROUS GENERATION SEEKETH AFTER A SIGN;
AND THERE SHALL NO SIGN (no miracle) BE GIVEN TO IT,
BUT THE SIGN (miracle) OF THE PROPHET JONAS:
FOR AS JONAS WAS THREE DAYS AND THREE NIGHTS IN THE WHALES BELLY;
SO SHALL THE SON OF MAN BE THREE DAYS AND THREE NIGHTS IN THE HEART OF THE EARTH.”
Jesus says, “NO SIGN.” He does not refer the Jews to blind Bartimeus whose sight he had restored. He does not speak about the “woman with issues” who was healed by merely touching him; or about the 2000 pigs he had destroyed to heal “a man possessed;” or the 5000 and the 3000 people he had fed and satiated with a few pieces of fish and a few pieces of bread. ‘No sign,” says Jesus, BUT ONE! -”THE SIGN OF THE PROPHET JONAS!” He is putting all his “eggs” in one basket. His claim to being the Messiah (Christ) stands or falls by the ONLY “sign” he was prepared to give.
Did Jesus fulfil the only sign he gave?
Christendom answers with a unanimous Y-E-S! without heeding the Biblical advice – ‘not to take things for granted.’ – but “PROVE ALL THINGS!”
(1 Thessalonians 5:21)
JONAH FLEES HIS CALL
What was the “sign” (miracle) of Jonah?
We have to go to the “Book of Jonah” in the Old Testament to find out.
God commanded Jonah to go to Nineveh and warn the Ninevites to repent from their “evil ways, and from the violence that is in their hands.”
But Jonah was loath to go as a warner unto the Ninevites, so he goes to Joppa instead of Ninevah, and takes a boat to run away from the Lords command.
While at sea, there was a terrible tempest. According to the superstition of the mariners, a person fleeing from his Masters command creates such a turmoil at sea.
They began to enquire among themselves and said, “COME, AND LET US CAST LOTS, (like the tossing of a coin, “head” or “tail”) THAT WE MAY KNOW FOR WHOSE CAUSE THIS EVIL IS UPON US. SO THEY CAST LOTS, AND THE LOT FELL UPON JONAH.” (Jonah 1:7)
Though there was a temporary lapse on the part of Jonah in fulfilling his mission, he manfully and most courageously volunteers: “AND HE SAID UNTO THEM TAKE ME UP, AND CAST ME FORTH INTO THE SEA; SO SHALL THE SEA BE CALM UNTO YOU: FOR I KNOW THAT FOR MY SAKE THIS GREAT TEMPEST IS UPON YOU.” (Jonah 1:12)
DEAD OR ALIVE?
Since Jonah was selflessly offering himself as a “vicarious” sacrifice there was no need for strangling him before throwing him into the sea, no need to spear him or break his arm or limb. In his own words: “TAKE ME UP AND CAST ME FORTH.”
The question now arises, that when the shipmaster and the crew threw him overboard, was Jonah dead or alive?
Any Christian child who has attended Sunday School will give an immediate reply: “ALIVE!”
The storm subsides. Was this perhaps a coincidence?
A fish swallows Jonah. Was he dead or alive when swallowed?
The answer again is “ALIVE”
Was he dead or alive when “JONAH PRAYED UNTO THE LORD HIS GOD OUT OF THE FISH’S BELLY?” (Jonah 2:1)
Surely dead men dont cry and dont pray!
The answer again is “ALIVE” For three days and three nights the fish takes him around the ocean: dead or alive? “ALIVE!” is the answer.
On the third day it vomits him on the seashore: dead or alive?
A-L-I-V-E, of course!
What had Jesus prophesied about himself?
He said: “AS JONAH WAS SO SHALL THE SON OF MAN BE” “soos Jonah” – “njenga Jonah” – LIKE JONAH. And how was Jonah? Was he dead or alive for three days and three nights? Alive! ALIVE! ALIVE! is the unanimous answer from the Jew, the Christian and the Muslim!
If Jonah was alive for three days and three nights, then Jesus also ought to have been alive in the tomb as he himself had foretold!
But Christianity hangs on the flimsy thread of the “death” of Jesus for its salvation. So it has to answer that Jesus was DEAD for three days and three nights.
The contradiction between his utterance and its fulfilment is obvious.
Jonah ALIVE, Jesus DEAD!
Very UNLIKE Jonah! Jesus had said “LIKE Jonah” not UNLIKE Jonah.
If this is true then according to his own test Jesus is not the TRUE Messiah of the Jews. If the Gospel record is genuine then how can we blame the Jews for rejecting “CHRIST.”
THREE DAYS AND THREE NIGHTS =72 HOURS ?
The Doctor of Divinity and the Professor of Theology replies that in Matthew 12:40 under discussion, the emphasis is on the TIME factor “as Jonas was THREE days and THREE nights in the belly of the whale, so shall the son of man be THREE days and THREE nights in the heart of the earth.”
“Please note,” says the learned theologian, “that the word “THREE” is repeated F-O-U-R times in this verse to prove that Jesus was going to fulfil the prophecy as regards the length of time he was going to remain in the tomb, and NOT ‘As Jonas was’ in relation to his being alive or dead.
If it is the time factor that Jesus was stressing then let us ask whether he fulfilled that aspect of his promise to the Jews as well. The Christian dogmatist answers: “OF COURSE!”
The question arises: when was Christ crucified?
The whole Christian world answers: “FRIDAY!”
Is this the reason we celebrate “Good Friday” “Gooi-Vrydag” – as a Public Holiday in the Republic of South Africa? And every Christian nation from America to Zambia, from Abyssinia to Zaire have a Public Holiday on the “FRIDAY” at Easter. What makes “Good Friday” so good?
“It is the death of Christ on the Cross on this day to wash off our sins,” says the Christians.
So he was killed on the cross on a Friday, 1950 years ago? “YES!” says the Christians.
From the Gospel records we gather that the Jews were in a hurry to eliminate Jesus.
Hence the midnight trial, and then despatching him off to Pilate in the morning;
from Pilate to Herod and then back again to Pilate.
The vested interests were afraid of the general public. Jesus was their hero. He had been their benefactor. His enemies had to do away with him quickly, and succeeded in doing so. However, as much as they were in a hurry to hang him on the cross, they were in equal hurry to bring him down from the cross before sunset on Friday because of the Sabbath. The Sabbath starts at about 6 p.m. on Friday and the Jews were warned in Deuteronomy 21:23 that the victim of crucifixion was an “accursed of God” and was not to be permitted to remain hanging on the Sabbath day, “that thy land be not defiled which the Lord thy God giveth thee for an inheritance.”
To satisfy the religious scruples of the Scribes and Pharisees the “secret disciples” of Jesus took down the body from the cross. They gave the body the Jewish burial-bath, plastered it with “one hundred pounds weight of aaloes and myrrh” (John 19:39), then placed the shrouded body into the sepulcher before night-fall.
There are numerous differences between the various sects and denominations of Christianity, but on the above they are unanimous.
Jesus is SUPPOSED to be in the tomb on the night of Friday.
He is still SUPPOSED to be in the tomb on the day of Saturday.
He is still SUPPOSED to be in the tomb on the night of Saturday.
Christians agree whole-heartedly with this.
It will be noted that I have repeated the word ‘SUPPOSED’ three times.
The reason is that the Gospels are silent as to when exactly Jesus came out of the tomb. He could have been taken away on Friday night by his “secret disciples” to a more congenial and restful place, but I have no right to assume about what the Gospel writers are silent.
I have, therefore, repeated the word ‘SUPPOSED’ three times.
In the final analysis, let us see whether Jesus was THREE days and THREE nights in the tomb:
In the final analysis, let us see whether Jesus was THREE days and THREE nights in the tomb:-
|EASTER WEEK||IN THE SEPULCHER|
|FRIDAY – placed in tomb just before sunset||– nil –||One night|
|SATURDAY – supposed to be in tomb||One day||One night|
|SUNDAY – missing before sunrise||– nil –||– nil –|
|TOTAL||One Day||Two Nights|
You will no doubt note that the GRAND TOTAL is ONE day and TWO nights, and NOT three days and three nights.
According to the Christian Scriptures Jesus had failed a SECOND time.
FIRST he was unlike Jonah, who was ALIVE in the belly of the fish, which is the exact opposite of what the Christians claim had happened to their master Jesus, who was DEAD for the same period of time as Jonah was – ALIVE.
SECONDLY, we discover that he also failed to fulfil the TIME FACTOR as well. The greatest mathematician in Christendom will fail to obtain the desired result – THREE days and THREE nights. We must not forget that the Gospels are explicit in telling us that it was “before sunrise” on Sunday morning (the FIRST day of the week), that Mary Magdalene went to the tomb of Jesus and found it empty.
Zakir Naik – Did Jesus Fulfill the Sign of Jonah
Permission is granted to circulate among private individuals and groups, to post on Internet sites and to publish in full text and subject title in not-for-profit publications
please check Our Blog For Daily Ahadees And Islamic Information